Variations in public construction projects in Uganda: causes, cost implications and governance weaknesses
Variations in public construction projects in Uganda: causes, cost implications and governance weaknesses
Date
2026
Authors
Byaruhanga, John William.
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Makerere University
Abstract
Variations are a common occurrence in construction projects and constitute an integral aspect of contract administration. However, in many public construction projects in Uganda, excessive and poorly managed variations have increasingly contributed to cost overruns, delays in project completion, contractual disputes, disruption of planned implementation, and reduced value for money in the utilization of public resources. This technical report examined variations in selected public construction projects in Uganda, with particular focus on their causes, cost implications, and governance weaknesses associated with their management. The study was grounded in the author’s professional involvement in the project management and contract administration of public infrastructure projects implemented under both government and donor-funded programmes. The principal case study was the Uganda Support to Municipal Infrastructure Development - Additional Financing [USMID-AF] Project implemented in Lugazi Municipal Council under Batch 2 from June 2022 to March 2025. To enrich the analysis, additional case studies were drawn from projects implemented under the same programme in Jinja City and Kamuli Municipality during the same period of June 2022 to March 2025. Additional projects that constituted the case studies were the Ssezibwa Bridge Reconstruction Project under the Ministry of Works and Transport that was commenced in June 2024 and is still ongoing, and the KIIDP2 Batch 1B implemented in Kampala Capital City Authority [KCCA] from September 2015 to April 2019. These projects constituted the Case Studies 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 in that order. The study adopted a qualitative case study approach supported by documentary review, project records analysis, professional observations, and thematic analysis. Data were obtained from contract documents, variation instructions/ change orders/variation orders, extension of time claims, payment certificates, project reports, meeting minutes, and relevant literature on construction variations and governance systems including standard forms of construction contracts, academic literature, textbooks, government policies and regulatory frameworks, and institutional reports. The findings established that inadequate design development and deficient BoQs were the primary drivers of variations. Other causes identified across the projects included technology upgrades, scope changes, inadequate project preparation, utility relocation requirements, land acquisition challenges, and time-related costs arising from extensions of time. Several projects experienced major design review adjustments shortly after commencement of construction, indicating weaknesses in pre-contract investigations and design development processes. The study further established that variations had significant cost implications on the selected projects. The reviewed projects experienced overall contract price increases ranging from approximately 5% to 19% above the original contract sums. The observed lower limit of approximately 5% exceeded the PPDA’s regulatory threshold of 1.5%, beyond which single or cumulated variations can no longer be treated as simple change orders approved solely by the Contract Manager and the Accounting Officer. This implies that the variations were substantial in nature and therefore required formal contract amendments subject to the requisite approvals of the Entity’s Contracts Committee and the Solicitor General [SG]. Furthermore, the observed upper limit of approximately 19% exceeded the PPDA’s regulatory threshold of not more than 15% applicable to a single contract amendment. This further demonstrates the magnitude and significance of the variations, to the extent that processing such adjustments under a single amendment would constitute statutory non compliance. These findings justify the conclusion that the variations, which largely originated from the implementation of design review recommendations, were indicative of deficiencies in project planning, design and overall project management processes. In addition to direct cost increases arising from additional works, variations resulted in increased preliminary and general costs during extended implementation periods, including prolonged site establishment obligations, supervision attendance costs, traffic management expenses, and environmental, safety, health and social compliance costs. Variations also contributed to delays in project completion and disruption of implementation schedules. The report further identified several governance weaknesses that influenced both the occurrence and management of variations. These included inadequate project preparation, delayed approvals and decision-making, weak coordination among stakeholders, delayed utility relocations, weak enforcement of regulatory requirements, funding constraints, and political interference in project implementation decisions. In some cases, approvals for variations were significantly delayed despite urgent implementation requirements, thereby contributing to additional downstream changes and project inefficiencies. In conclusion, although variations are inevitable in construction projects, many of the variations experienced in Ugandan public construction projects arise from avoidable weaknesses in planning, design management, governance systems, and contract administration practices. Effective mitigation of excessive variations therefore requires improvements in project preparation, design reviews, stakeholder coordination, regulatory compliance, timely decision-making, and proactive supervision throughout the project lifecycle. The report recommends strengthening feasibility studies and detailed engineering designs before procurement, improving quality assurance during preparation of Bills of Quantities and contract documentation, enhancing coordination among implementing agencies and utility providers, enforcing regulatory approval requirements for variations, and strengthening institutional capacity in public-sector contract management. The report further recommends adoption of proactive project governance and supervision systems aimed at improving accountability, minimizing avoidable variations, and enhancing value for money in public infrastructure development.
Description
A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Master Of Science in Construction Management of Makerere University
Keywords
Citation
Byaruhanga, J. W. (2026). Variations in public construction projects in Uganda: causes, cost implications and governance weaknesses; Unpublished Masters dissertation, Makerere University, Kampala.