Labour-based district gravel road maintainance through contractor capacity building and resource optimization: a case study of Pallisa district in Uganda
Labour-based district gravel road maintainance through contractor capacity building and resource optimization: a case study of Pallisa district in Uganda
Date
2026
Authors
Kirungudha, Godfrey.
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Makerere University
Abstract
Gravel roads provide essential access to markets and services in rural Uganda, but their maintenance is constrained by limited resources and competing demands for cost efficiency, timely delivery and local employment. Evidence on how labour and equipment can be combined under district-level conditions remains limited. This study examined labour–equipment deployment and productivity, compared maintenance costs and execution times, and explored perceptions of site-based training and contractor operational capacity in Pallisa District. A mixed-methods case study was conducted between February and May 2025 on four purposively selected gravel roads and three maintenance firms. The achieved sample comprised 161 participants, including 91 workers, three contractor representatives and 67 local government and community representatives. Data included field observations, questionnaire responses, key informant interviews, maintenance cost schedules and activity records. Quantitative data were summarised using descriptive statistics and unit-cost calculations, while qualitative responses were analysed thematically. Observed operations combined manual slashing and drainage clearance with mechanised carriageway grading. Slashing and drainage-related activities accounted for 81.4% of the recorded labour input. The activity-productivity calculations used assumed outputs and therefore did not establish an optimal labour–equipment ratio. For two recorded road packages, estimated labour-based costs were UGX 6.36 million/km on Pallisa Agule and UGX 6.93 million/km on Pallisa–Gogonyo, compared with equipment-based costs of UGX 8.00 million/km and UGX 8.18 million/km, respectively. Labour-based costs were approximately 20.5% and 15.3% lower relative to the corresponding equipment-based costs. Activity schedules suggested earlier completion under the equipment-based approach, although the timings were approximate and comparability in work quantities, initial needs and quality was assumed. The worker sample included 32 skilled and 59 semi-skilled participants, demonstrating the involvement of both groups in maintenance. These figures do not quantify jobs created by either approach. Respondents perceived practical training as beneficial to skills and work organisation, but its independent effect was not measured. The findings support task-specific coordination of labour and equipment, accompanied by supervision, training and reliable resource provision. Improved records of outputs, costs, time, quality and employment are needed to guide future optimisation.
Description
A dissertation submitted to the Directorate of Post Graduate Training for the award of Masters of Civil Engineering of Makerere University
Keywords
Citation
Kirungudha, G. (2026). Labour-based district gravel road maintainance through contractor capacity building and resource optimization: a case study of Pallisa district in Uganda; Unpublished Masters dissertation, Makerere University, Kampala.